All Answers (6)
Answer from a Designer
There is no definitive answer for the perfect kitchen. If removing the island will free up much need floor space, then don't hesitate to take it out. However, make sure you will still have ample counter surface for proper food prep. If you are on the fence, consider small, portable island units like this one from WSHome http://bit.ly/GzJo86. Who says you can't have it all!
Answer from a Designer
Trends aren't personal and kitchens are very personal. I'd suggest being practical and functional for the cook(s). Ideally, the layout functions for prep/cooking, conversation, and family/guests to keep you company. Creating the very best space to work in is still the most important thing. Without knowing about the surrounding spaces, it's difficult to say if the 'U' is the best option for you.
Answer from an Architect
Inside corners in a kitchen are a challenge. It's difficult to avoid wasting space and easy to create problems. You can add lazy susans or fold out shelves but you still don't get the full use of the space. So really consider whether you will actually gain enough usable space to make the project worth it.
I'm thinking of doing the same thing! I have an island now & I feel like I'm constantly going in circles around it. I just can't figure out the best way to place the sink, fridge, stove work triangle....
Answer from a Designer
I would say yes, that it is counter to current trends, which are showing increasing importance on social interaction in the kitchen as well as more family members than ever, both immediate family and multiple generations using the kitchen together which means freedom of movement is a valuable feature for social and functional reasons. Each design has its pros and cons. You may have found more pros than cons in moving to a U shape and if that works for you, it's the right answer!
Answer from a Designer
Without knowing exactly what your kitchen's floor plan is in relation to other rooms, it's hard to say. I think it would depend on the flow of the space. An island works well because you can still have traffic on all sides. U shaped may close in the space and create a bottleneck, especially when entertaining. My experience is that people tend to congregate in the kitchen and especially around an island. I would advise you to really think about how you live and utilize your kitchen to see which would make the most sense for you. Good luck!
Add Your Answer